The ethics world cup

Twb Article 3 min read

It’s starting to feel old. Yet another week and yet another reason to question the ethics of those who govern football. 

Author

S'bo Gyre

Published

March , 2022

If it isn’t greedy billionaire club owners creating closed leagues, it’s questions of sports-washing and financial doping. Football is ethical, as they would say, in the pits. As yet another fortnight of boring international friendlies and World Cup qualifiers take place, the integrity of the host nation of FIFA’s showpiece event has yet again come into question. 

Considering it’s been 12 years since Qatar won the right to host the almost century-old tournament, scrutiny has become expected.

Any new concerns have not come as a surprise to those with knowledge of the middle eastern country’s questionable human rights record. The football community’s passive resistance has also not been untrue to form. Money makes the football world go round and the Qatar is have lots of it.

The financial gains of a World Cup in Qatar have been far too tempting for FIFA to resist. An organization whose execution of its duty of care to its own players is questionable, to say the least, it somehow still shocks many that human rights violations are not top of their list of concerns when making such important endorsements. “In the prime of their lives” is the title of the report by Amnesty International that reveals the truth of how thousands of migrant workers have lost their lives whilst constructing the stadiums due to being used for the tournament. The number of deaths as of 2020 was 6 500 according to the UK publication, The Guardian.

That number of deaths is staggering and particularly worrying when allegations of forced labor have surfaced. Add to those regressive laws against LGBTQIA+ people and women and it isn’t hard to understand why concerns extend beyond workers but also towards thousands of diverse fans of the game making their way to the oil-rich state. 

Cultural differences are an important nuance to consider when scrutinizing the socio-political state of the country however it does not exempt these differences from criticism. There is no doubt that the Qatari state has made a concerted effort to sports-wash.

 From the acquisition of French club PSG to this tournament, the long build-up since Qatar was named as hosts has seen them become more aggressive in their sports-washing antics.It’s not uncommon now to see Qatar Airways as shirt sponsors and PSG chairman Nasser Al-Khelaifi is now chairman of the European Clubs Association (ECA). The fact that a financial doper will now oversee the dispensation of new Financial Fair Play rules is evidence of the vice the Qataris have over world football.

This isn’t to say the funds and resources plunged into the game have not been beneficial however the situation is ought to be looked at holistically. The question is what does football do in the immediate and long term?

Protests from players and FAs have been few and far between. The most overt opposition to Qatar hosting has been Norway. In 2021, Haaland and co wore training shirts written “Human Rights: On and off the pitch”. Denmark and The Netherlands have been the other two nations on record condemning FIFA and the state of Qatar.

England manager Gareth Southgate has revealed his players have been briefed by experts on social issues in Qatar. This commendable gesture should help footballers be more mindful of such issues and subsequently speak on them with a greater conviction of their stance. Footballers aren’t politicians but they are role models and public features. If they are to be vehicles to drive change, the fuel they need is expert-level knowledge to form unequivocal convictions on the matter.  

Harry Kane has expressed “confliction” over his participation as a result. We cannot reasonably expect players to boycott a competition that only takes place once every four years, having worked for years towards it, especially when they had no power over who the hosts are. It is however fair to expect well-informed and honest reflections. This is the only way they could win the ethics World Cup.

Written by 

S'bo Gyre (@FootballFemmes)
Creative Nation Magazine
What a Time to be African: A Triumph of Unity and Inspiration

In the crisp autumn of 2023, the echoes of victory still reverberate through the hearts of millions across the African continent. The Springboks, with their triumphant win at the Rugby World Cup, etched not just their names in history but crafted an inspiring narrative of unity and inspiration for a generation.

Creative Nation Magazine
Premier League 30 Africa XI : Lucas Redebe

On Thursday, 29 June, campaign ambassador, Bafana Bafana and Leeds United legend, Lucas Radebe was in conversation with SuperSport’s Lwazi Ziqubu to discuss his involvement in the initiative, in the presence of a live audience as well as viewers tuning in via a live stream.

Creative Nation Magazine
Qatar 2022 : The World Cup of Politics

It's been another four year cycle and the world is feasting its eyes on football's greatest showpiece event. Qatar 2022 is guaranteed to offer lots of unforgettable sporting moments

Creative Nation Magazine
Standom robbed me of Messi

Argentina versus France was the blockbuster finale that has millions tantalisingly expectant, as the Qatari-hosted showpiece comes to an end.

Creative Nation Magazine
Why this title means more to Pep

Success is not foreign to Pep Guardiola- the furthest thing from it. In his 13 years in management, he has won an impressive 10 league titles in 3 of Europe's top 5 leagues. Yet somehow, after clinching the Premier League title this Sunday he was in tears.

Creative Nation Magazine
Klopp’s astute Liverpool Rebuild

Time is proving that his inability to rebuild his Dortmund team after their back to back league titles and a UCL final run has taught Klopp invaluable lessons

Creative Nation Magazine
Banter FC: Red Devils In Hell

There has never been a more emotionally taxing time to be a Manchester United supporter in the modern era. No one wants to be “Banter FC” but the truth is, that is exactly who United is right now.

Creative Nation Magazine
Die-NYSTY : The Shortfalls of success

For a second year running, the race for the Scudetto does not include the “old lady”, Juventus. To all but the fans of the Bianconeri, this is a welcome shift in the Italian footballing landscape.

Creative Nation Magazine
The ethics world cup

It’s starting to feel old. Yet another week and yet another reason to question the ethics of those who govern football.

Creative Nation Magazine
Not so real Madrid

Not many in world football could’ve predicted the mauling Real Madrid would have at the hands of eternal rivals, FC Barcelona.

Creative Nation Magazine
What about the sports -washed ?

What’s a football fan to do in the face of their sports-washing owner?

Creative Nation Magazine
What is the whistle blower?

The Whistle Blower (#TWB) is a platform where unfashionable football takes have a home.

Creative Nation Magazine is a digital publication that celebrates and showcases the diverse creative talent of our nation. Our magazine provides a platform for artists, writers, photographers, and musicians to share their work with a wider audience.